Ask people to name New York City’s best mayor, and the answers tend to reveal what they value most in city leadership.
For many Staten Islanders, the qualities that matter most are straightforward: public safety, clean streets, effective management, strong city services, and a sense that New York is being run with order and direction. When those standards are applied, one former mayor continues to stand out more than most.
Why Rudy Giuliani Still Gets So Much Attention
For many New Yorkers, Rudy Giuliani remains closely associated with a period when the city felt more controlled, more orderly, and more focused on quality-of-life issues.
Supporters often point to the 1990s as a time when crime fell, public spaces improved, and the city projected a stronger sense of structure. For those who see mayoral success through the lens of visible day-to-day change, Giuliani is often viewed as the figure most tied to that shift.
That does not mean everyone agrees with his legacy in every respect, but it does explain why his name continues to come up so often when the conversation turns to mayoral impact.
Bloomberg Still Holds Strong Appeal
Michael Bloomberg is another former mayor who continues to draw respect, especially from those who value managerial competence and a steady hand in running a large city.
His time in office is often associated with efficiency, economic development, and a style of leadership that emphasized administration, long-term planning, and business-minded governance. For many residents, Bloomberg represents a different kind of strength: less rhetorical, more operational.
Koch Remains Part of the Conversation
Ed Koch also continues to hold a lasting place in New York political memory.
For many longtime New Yorkers, Koch represents an earlier era of strong city identity and visible leadership. His years in office remain part of the broader story of how the city evolved in the decades before later administrations reshaped public perception of safety, development, and daily life.
What People Usually Mean by “Best Mayor”
The question of who was best is rarely just about personality.
More often, it comes down to results. People tend to judge mayors by whether they believe the city felt safer, cleaner, more affordable, better managed, or more stable during that period. That is why different names appeal to different voters. Some focus on crime and quality of life. Others focus on economic growth, infrastructure, housing, or historical impact.
In the end, the answer usually says as much about the voter’s priorities as it does about the mayor.
The Bottom Line
When the subject of New York City’s best mayor comes up, Rudy Giuliani still stands out for many Staten Islanders, especially among those who place the greatest value on public safety, order, and visible city improvement.
At the same time, figures like Michael Bloomberg and Ed Koch remain part of the conversation, showing that New Yorkers continue to judge leadership through the lens of the era they remember most strongly.rs.
Read Next
More stories from around Staten Island
Staten Island Neighbors Reaches 50,000 Members as Community Network Continues Rapid Growth
MTA Fare Inspectors Seen Checking Staten Island Buses Near Ferry Terminal
