For all the jokes, traffic complaints, and endless bridge debates, one theme continues to come up whenever Staten Islanders talk about home: the borough still feels unlike anywhere else in New York City.
From tree-lined neighborhoods and sprawling parks to old-school pizzerias and family-run bakeries, many residents say Staten Island offers something harder to find in the rest of the city — space, familiarity, and a quieter pace of life.
The “Suburban NYC” Identity
A major reason many residents say they love Staten Island is the balance between city access and suburban living.
Several locals described the borough as offering “the best of both worlds” — detached homes, driveways, yards, and quieter neighborhoods while still remaining connected to Manhattan and the rest of New York City.
Others pointed to one of Staten Island’s most commonly celebrated luxuries: parking.
The absence of alternate side parking rules was repeatedly mentioned as one of the borough’s most underrated advantages, especially compared to other parts of the city.
Parks, Beaches, and Green Space Still Define the Borough
Residents also overwhelmingly highlighted Staten Island’s parks, beaches, and natural scenery as some of its biggest strengths.
Locals described the borough as NYC’s “borough of parks,” pointing to destinations like the Greenbelt, Clove Lakes Park, Silver Lake Park, and the South Shore waterfront as reasons Staten Island feels different from the city’s more densely packed boroughs.
Many longtime residents said the greenery, hiking trails, waterfront views, and quieter residential streets continue to give Staten Island a small-town atmosphere that’s become increasingly rare in New York City.
Food Culture Remains a Point of Pride
As expected, food quickly became one of the most praised parts of Staten Island life.
Pizza, bagels, bakeries, Italian delis, and neighborhood restaurants were repeatedly described as some of the best in the city.
Classic Staten Island staples like Ralph’s Ices, neighborhood pizzerias, Italian bakeries, and longtime family-owned restaurants continue to shape much of the borough’s identity.
A Borough Built Around Community and Family
Beyond food and parks, many residents emphasized something less tangible: community.
Several Staten Islanders described growing up in neighborhoods where families knew one another for generations, kids played together outside, and neighbors still looked out for each other.
Others reflected on how the borough has changed over the years, with some longtime residents nostalgic for a quieter Staten Island from decades past. Still, even many critics admitted there remains a strong sense of local identity that keeps people emotionally tied to the borough.
The Ferry Still Represents Staten Island to Many Residents
For many locals, few things feel more “Staten Island” than the Staten Island Ferry.
Residents repeatedly mentioned the ferry ride, skyline views, and Statue of Liberty scenery as one of the borough’s defining experiences — especially at sunset or during late-night rides into Manhattan.
Why Staten Island Continues to Stand Out
While opinions varied on whether Staten Island is truly “the best borough,” one thing became clear throughout the discussion: Staten Islanders tend to have a deep emotional connection to the place itself.
Whether it’s the parks, pizza, waterfront views, neighborhood pride, or simply the feeling of growing up somewhere that still feels personal, Staten Island continues to maintain a character many residents believe is difficult to replicate anywhere else in New York City.
Read Next
More stories from around Staten Island
Staten Island Weekly News Roundup: Top Local Stories and Neighborhood Updates (Week Ending Sunday, May 17, 2026)
Staten Island’s Favorite Cannoli Spots in 2026
