Best Burgers on Staten Island

August 7, 2026•Staten Island Neighbors

Few foods spark more debate on Staten Island than a great burger.

We recently asked members of the Staten Island Neighbors community one simple question:

Who has the best burgers on Staten Island?

Hundreds of residents joined the conversation, sharing recommendations that ranged from longtime neighborhood favorites to classic diners, local taverns, and even restaurants that have been gone for decades. While everyone has their own personal favorite, several businesses stood out with repeated recommendations from community members.

Whether you’re looking for a classic cheeseburger, a charcoal-grilled burger, or a neighborhood bar known for great food, these are some of the burger spots Staten Islanders recommended most.

Community Favorites

🍔 Duffy’s

Duffy’s emerged as one of the community’s most frequently recommended burger destinations. Many residents praised its signature burgers served on English muffins, while others shared memories of visiting for years with family and friends.

🍔 Griff’s Place

Griff’s earned repeated recommendations throughout the discussion, with many residents calling it one of Staten Island’s top burger spots.

🍔 Joyce’s Tavern

A longtime neighborhood favorite, Joyce’s Tavern received numerous recommendations for its burgers and classic tavern atmosphere.

🍔 Andrew’s Diner

Andrew’s Diner was another business consistently mentioned by residents looking for a great traditional burger.

🍔 Rock House Bar & Grill

Rock House Bar & Grill earned praise from community members and continues to be one of Staten Island’s popular burger destinations.

🍔 Rab’s Country Lanes

Known for more than just bowling, Rab’s also received multiple recommendations from residents for its burgers.

🍔 Hop Shoppe

Hop Shoppe was another favorite among the community, earning repeated mentions throughout the discussion.

🍔 Ralph’s Sports Bar

Ralph’s Sports Bar received several recommendations from residents who consider it one of Staten Island’s go-to spots for burgers.

🍔 Trackside Bar & Grill

Trackside rounded out many residents’ lists of favorite local burger destinations.

Honorable Mentions

Several other restaurants also received recommendations from community members, including Chili’s, Shake Shack, Tommy’s Tavern, and even White Castle, proving that great burgers can be found in all kinds of places across Staten Island.

Staten Island’s Burger History Lives On

One of the most interesting parts of the discussion wasn’t just today’s favorites—it was the memories.

Residents fondly remembered legendary Staten Island burger spots like Bacci’s Charcoal Haven, Burger Chef, Wetson’s, A&W, Country Club Diner, King’s Arms, Victory Lanes Snack Bar, and Corner House. While some of these businesses are no longer around, they continue to hold a special place in the memories of longtime Staten Islanders.

Sometimes the Best Burger Isn’t at a Restaurant

One theme appeared throughout the conversation more than many expected: for countless residents, the best burger isn’t served by any restaurant at all.

Many said their favorite burger comes straight off a backyard charcoal grill, cooked by a parent, grandparent, spouse, or friend. It was a reminder that, for many Staten Islanders, great food is often connected to family traditions just as much as flavor.

About Community Favorites

Community Favorites is a Staten Island Neighbors series highlighting the restaurants, businesses, services, and places most recommended by our community.

Rather than relying on critics or paid rankings, these articles are built from recommendations shared by Staten Island residents to help others discover trusted local businesses and make informed decisions.

Have an idea for a future Community Favorites article? Let us know!