Few topics spark more passionate debate on Staten Island than pizza.
To launch our new Community Favorites series, we asked members of the Staten Island Neighbors community a simple question:
Who has the best pizza on Staten Island?
Hundreds of residents shared their recommendations, highlighting longtime neighborhood institutions, family-owned pizzerias, and hidden gems across the borough. While there was no unanimous winner, several restaurants stood out with repeated recommendations from community members.
Whether you’re searching for a classic New York-style slice, a crispy tavern pie, a Sicilian square, or a specialty pie, these are some of the pizza spots Staten Islanders recommended most.
Community Favorites
🍕 Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern
A Staten Island institution for generations, Denino’s was one of the community’s most frequently recommended pizzerias. Many residents praised its classic thin-crust pies and traditional pizzeria experience.
🍕 Brothers Pizzeria
Brothers received an overwhelming number of recommendations, with many community members specifically mentioning its popular Sicilian pizza.
🍕 Lee’s Tavern
Known for its famous tavern-style pizzas, Lee’s Tavern continues to be a longtime favorite among Staten Islanders and was one of the most frequently mentioned businesses in our community discussion.
🍕 Joe & Pat’s Pizzeria
A neighborhood staple with a loyal following, Joe & Pat’s was repeatedly recommended for its classic New York-style pizza.
🍕 Pizza Giove
One of the newer favorites to emerge in recent years, Pizza Giove earned numerous recommendations from residents throughout the community.
🍕 Ciro’s
Ciro’s received consistent praise from community members, with many calling it one of Staten Island’s best-kept pizza traditions.
🍕 Jimmy Max
Known for its specialty pies as well as traditional pizza, Jimmy Max was another business frequently recommended by residents.
🍕 Round Pie Pizza Company
Round Pie appeared throughout the discussion, with many residents praising its unique style and quality.
🍕 Nonna’s Pizzeria
Nonna’s earned repeated recommendations from community members, particularly those on the South Shore.
🍕 Campania
Campania rounded out many residents’ personal top lists and continues to be one of Staten Island’s most talked-about pizzerias.
Honorable Mentions
Many other pizzerias also received recommendations from the community, including:
Mona Lisa • Il Forno • Palermo • Villa Monte • Mimmo’s • Cafe Milano • Mr. Pizza • Parma • La Piazza • Rustic Pizza • Dough by Licastri • Ungaro’s • Bari Pizza • Goodfellas • DaFarina • Mama Rosaria • Breaking Bread • Sal & Lloyd’s • Domenico’s • La Vera • Napoli Pizzeria • Plaza Pizza • Prime Pizza Kitchen • Gennaro’s • Tony’s Brick Oven • Torino Pizza • Ambrosino’s • Pronto • Vesuvio Trattoria and many more.
Every Pizza Lover Has a Favorite
One thing quickly became clear: there isn’t a single “best” pizza on Staten Island.
Some residents prefer a classic thin-crust pie, while others swear by Sicilian squares, grandma pies, vodka pies, or artisan-style pizza. That’s what makes Staten Island’s pizza scene so unique—there’s something for every taste.
If you’ve never visited one of the pizzerias on this list, consider giving it a try. You might just discover your new favorite.
About Community Favorites
Community Favorites is a Staten Island Neighbors series highlighting the businesses, restaurants, services, and places most recommended by our community.
Rather than relying on critics or paid rankings, these articles are built from recommendations shared by Staten Island residents to help others discover trusted local businesses and make informed decisions.
Have an idea for a future Community Favorites article? Let us know!
Read Next
More stories from around Staten Island
Best Cannolis on Staten Island
Best Burgers on Staten Island
