STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. — A recent discussion in the public Staten Island Neighbors community sparked hundreds of comments as residents shared their opinions on one simple question: Who has the best donuts on Staten Island? The conversation quickly turned into a borough-wide roundup of favorite bakeries, neighborhood shops, and longtime local traditions.
Among all the recommendations, Country Donuts emerged as the most frequently mentioned shop, with dozens of residents praising its fresh donuts, consistent quality, and longtime reputation. While no official poll was conducted, the volume of comments made it the clear standout in this particular community discussion.
Several other Staten Island favorites also received significant support from residents, including Holtermann’s Bakery, Sal’s Bakery, Annadale Bakery, Mark’s Bake Shoppe, Donut World, Bella Baci, Piece A Cake, and Alfonso’s Pastry Shoppe. National chains such as Krispy Kreme, Tim Hortons, and Dunkin’ were also mentioned, though local bakeries dominated the conversation.
The discussion highlighted how different shops have earned loyal followings for different specialties. Residents singled out Sal’s Bakery for its generously filled jelly donuts and specialty flavors, while Mark’s Bake Shoppe was repeatedly praised for its crumb donuts and jelly rings. Holtermann’s Bakery continued to earn recognition as a Staten Island institution, and Annadale Bakery received praise for its fresh selection, with some commenters noting that popular varieties often sell out early.
Food discussions have become some of the most active conversations within the Staten Island Neighbors community, giving residents an opportunity to exchange recommendations while introducing others to businesses they may not have visited before. As more neighbors participate, these conversations continue to showcase the diversity of Staten Island’s locally owned bakeries and small businesses.
While tastes inevitably vary, one thing was clear from this discussion: Staten Islanders are passionate about their donuts. From classic glazed and old-fashioned varieties to jelly-filled favorites and specialty creations, the borough offers no shortage of places that have earned devoted customers over the years.
Most Frequently Mentioned Donut Shops in This Discussion
- Country Donuts
- Holtermann’s Bakery
- Sal’s Bakery
- Annadale Bakery
- Mark’s Bake Shoppe
- Donut World
- Bella Baci
- Piece A Cake
- Alfonso’s Pastry Shoppe
- Heartland Bagels
Editor’s Note: This article summarizes recommendations shared by members of the Staten Island Neighbors community. It reflects opinions expressed by residents and is not a ranked review or endorsement by SINeighbors.com.
Read Next
More stories from around Staten Island
What Staten Islanders Were Talking About in July 2026
Ralph’s Ices Gift Card Giveaway Winners Announced
