STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. — One simple question sparked one of the Staten Island Neighbors community’s most active political discussions:
“If you could bring back a past Mayor of New York City, who would it be?”
Hundreds of Staten Islanders weighed in, sharing memories of past administrations while debating crime, public safety, leadership, and how New York City has changed over the years.
Although several names entered the conversation, one former mayor clearly stood out as the community’s most frequently mentioned choice.
Rudy Giuliani Was the Clear Favorite
Across the discussion, Rudy Giuliani received the overwhelming majority of mentions from community members.
Supporters frequently pointed to his time in office during the 1990s, describing it as a period when they believed New York City experienced lower crime, cleaner streets, and a greater sense of public safety.
Many residents shared personal memories of commuting into Manhattan, raising families, and feeling more comfortable throughout the city during Giuliani’s administration.
For those commenters, those experiences remain closely tied to how they remember his years as mayor.
Not Everyone Shared the Same View
While Giuliani received the largest share of support, the discussion also featured plenty of opposing opinions.
Some residents argued that his later legal troubles and public controversies should be considered alongside his accomplishments as mayor. Others questioned how much credit should be given to any single administration for New York City’s changes during that era.
As additional comments poured in, the conversation expanded beyond individual mayors and became a broader discussion about policing, quality of life, taxes, homelessness, and the future direction of New York City.
The Discussion Became About More Than Politics
As often happens within the Staten Island Neighbors community, the conversation evolved beyond the original question.
Many residents reflected on the neighborhoods they grew up in, the way New York City has changed over the decades, and the qualities they believe make an effective mayor.
Rather than focusing solely on political parties, many comments centered on personal experiences and memories of living and working in the city during different administrations.
Why It Matters
Questions like these often reveal more than just political preferences.
They provide a snapshot of how Staten Islanders remember the city’s history and the issues that continue to matter most to residents today.
Whether people agreed or disagreed, the discussion demonstrated how conversations about New York City’s leadership continue to generate thoughtful debate across the community.
Community Discussion
If you could bring back one former New York City mayor, who would you choose—and why?
Hundreds of Staten Islanders have already shared their opinions. Continue the conversation by visiting the original Facebook discussion.
Read Next
More stories from around Staten Island
Inside East Hana Staten Island: Sushi, Ramen & All-You-Can-Eat Japanese Dining
Staten Island Neighbors Reaches 50,000 Members as Community Network Continues Rapid Growth
